Home
Anglesmile

Vesuvian Party

Mainly to LJ folk - you may recall that sometime back, LJ was sold by its founder to a company called Six Apart. They promptly updated the Livejournal social contract, original seen here (click for larger):

In order to remove the (circled) clause promising that they would never put advertising on the site. Six Apart, having broken the social contract with its users, has still tread lightly on the matter. In other countries it has been building partnerships with businesses which do their own advertising.

A few days ago, Six Apart announced that they're selling LJ to one of these partners - a Russian advertising/marketing firm by the name of SUP. I have no doubt that this will harm the community, at the very least changing that low-key violation of the social contract into a flagrant disregard. I hope it won't be on the scale that broke up many of the social projects I was involved with in the past such as NoWonder, but I would not be surprised. One thing I'm pretty certain of is that it will not be better - when was the last time a company you had dealings with was improved by an acquisition?

Slight additional detail:

  • An "advisory board" is to be formed from industry experts and "community members", according to an email. If you think about how this will be selected, this should give you no fuzzy feelings
  • There's to be an "exclusive party" open to .. everyone who got these announcements, which is potentially the entire LJ community... which is about as exclusive as ... hehe .. all to "celebrate" this.

To dream what jwz might say about this, "I, for one, welcome our new Russian marketing overlords".

Tags:

Comments

An "advisory board" is to be formed from industry experts and "community members", according to an email. If you think about how this will be selected, this should give you no fuzzy feelings

This apparently will be including [info]brad, which is something.

Edited at 2007-12-04 03:25 am (UTC)
I fact, I believe [info]brad did say something to the effect of, "I welcome our new Russian overlords."

Yes, the fact that [info]brad is included helps a bit for me, especially since he was against a lot of what 6Apart did.

I don't trust SUP much though, especially in the current Russian political climate. (At least I can assume Putin doesn't care what I write though.) I've already started setting up an account at InsaneJournal, though I don't know when or if I'll move there.
What do advisory boards do? What expectations do you think there'll be of Brad? Might he be under any obligations, legal or otherwise, to make things work? Unlike a marriage, divorcing this group will be practically impossible - to use a bit of a charged phrase/idea, LJ is the Arab wife.

I once knew a guy by the name of Scott William who sold a group called NoWonder to .. actually, see here for a bit more info. Without a formal responsibility to the community, I don't think we can trust them, especially if the most we know we'll have is someone who already okayed going back on community principles (i.e. Brad). The owners will be a Russian marketing firm, a group even less likely to pay attention to angry customers than an American firm (as Russian capitalism is very raw right now).

Edited at 2007-12-04 10:14 pm (UTC)