Pat Gunn (dachte) wrote,
Pat Gunn

Feeding the Searle Lions

To briefly revisit Searle, which I blogged about a long time ago and of whom I've heard a lot about recently (Chinese Room argument), the main point of Searle, as I see it, is to jar people by making them realise that in Searle's systm, the person does not understand Chinese, and to expect them to find it absurd to consider anything else. The right solution, that the system as a whole understands Chinese, is not intuitively satisfying, because we don't like attaching understanding, something core to what it means to be human, to a more abstract system. In this mind experiment, by delving into assigning intelligence/understanding to something nonliving and abstract, Searle extends emotive understanding to try to make us reject the position he dislikes, although to do so takes us away from what would be, in my opinon, the position we'd reach after sufficient careful thought. Searle thus, in my understanding, acts as a deliberate voice for emotional blindness to truth. Searle's response, a suggestion to memorise the rule book, is just another obfuscation in that it does not eliminate the "system" aspect, it just disguises one of the players. Searle's question is not interesting in itself -- at best, it can act as a dead-animal doormat inviting people into a more interesting room of honest discussion on the mind. That is all.


  • CMU, the First Amendment, and Indecent Exposure

    Earlier on my G+ stream, I commented on the matter of a CMU student who protested the Catholic church's coverup of sexual abuse by dressing as the…

  • Dilution

    I've been thinking about an issue that's been raised in the secular community; I'm not sure it's a good issue, nor a bad one. Let me lead up to it…

  • Commentary on the Human Rights Campaign

    I recently was pointed at a blog post suggesting people reject the Human Rights Campaign, a large social justice organisation that focuses on…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded