Pat Gunn (dachte) wrote,
Pat Gunn

  • Music:

D and N

From a recent conversation, paraphrased:

"Do you consider yourself more of a nerd or a geek?

  • Hmm. A geek.
  • Then MIT would be better than Harvard.
Amusing how short conversations show that the cloud of (sometimes-separate, sometimes overlapping) definitions one has can differ from someone else's, and also how such a short definition can add a new member to that cloud. Memes in action!

I am lightly tempted to observe that for entirely different definitions of terms, geeks seek to create a new culture to replace their existing one, while nerds are cultural nihilists - geeks might consider the connection sound of the modem, a now largely obsolete device that some geeks have probably never heard in actual use, as a rallying call while nerds, being both more solitary and often more academic, wouldn't even have the urge for that kind of thing. Geeks might celebrate the idea of the comic mad scientist (a la Dr Forrester of MST3k or more recently Dr Horrible) while Nerds would more seriously resemble one. But ... I suspect going too far in this direction would lead to the kind of rubbish that Eric Raymond has given us with his self-description in the jargon file - fun to read in a fortune-teller way, but more a caricature than accurate.

Hmm. I have not climbed in too long.


  • Lessons about Humanity, from Mars

    As many of you already know, yesterday NASA's MSL-Curiosity rover discovered something, or so we think, in a chemical sample taken on Mars. They…

  • Apish Tongues

    (Apologies for the cross-post with plus, but after I posted this there I realised it's probably more bloglike in character) I have a fascination…

  • Ancient Periscopes

    Three sciency things: Lake Ellsworth, a lake in Antarctica buried deep under the ice, is to have a probe visit it to take samples of the water and…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded