Pat Gunn (dachte) wrote,
Pat Gunn

In defense of Hipsters

Before I get into this topic, let me add the following disclaimer: I have never met anyone who seemed to me to be clearly a hipster. I may be talking a lot about something I don't know anything about. If I'm full of it or you just disagree, don't be shy about letting me know (this goes in general too).

In Defense of Hipsters:Over the last few years, I've seen considerable anti-hipster ranting/mockery and other cultural content. Not really understanding hipsters as a subculture, I initially wondered if I might be a hipster; is there overlap between academic-flavoured no-woo intellectuals and hipster? Am I in that overlap? I've tried to find reasonable non-hating definitions of hipster subculture, and as far as I can tell, I probably am not a hipster, but have a fair number of things in common with them. Still, I am uncomfortable with the harsh critiques of hipsterism.

I am bothered in part because I think hipsters seem to be a cousin to (or overlap significantly with) intellectuals and the criticism feels too close to general anti-intellectualism in the United States. One of the dominant themes in American culture, and a major failing here, is that we value folksiness; we turn our back on the highest accomplishments in culture and science and technology, and we resent the idea of accomplishment and scientific and cultural virtue. We praise simple ignorance over complicated intellectual life; many of us yearn for simpler days devoid of complication. The hipster, even if it is something specific, is also a stereotype of country folk towards city folk. The fast-moving, complicated nuances of a city folk with acquired tastes, constructing and deconstructing new norms all the time rather than having relatively static life of country folk make the hipster just more city than most city folk, and an easy target for misunderstandings and a retreat from the values of civilisation. What are we afraid of with hipsters? Novelty? Being disapproved of? Being too slow to be in their notion of the loop?

I am also bothered in part because some of the specifics of what I read of Hipster subculture seem good things, even apart from their overlap with intellectuals. For one, I am very very enthusiastic about the idea of cultural appropriation and an international/anational identity. For another, anti-traditionalism. Much of the irritation I have with criticism of hipsters has to do with people who have a problem with cultural appropriation.

In sum, it feels to me like hipsters arn't really doing anything that isn't either very understandable as being part of human nature, that hipsters are essentially an archetypes of city folk, that hipster culture has some pretty fantastic things about it, and that the opposition to hipsters is a form of (or at least related to) general American anti-intellectualism and anti-city-folk-ism.

From what I've read, I'd rather surround myself with hipsters than people who are proud to be beer-guzzling TV-watching people whose mental lives are relatively static. Hipsters may not exactly be my people, but they're closer to my idea of the right thing. Probably. Not having met any, I can't say for certain. If the "it's not cool if lots of people know about it" might feel a bit silly to me, but I don't need their judgement that I'm cool anyhow. If anti-hipsterism significantly involves injured pride, mine is fairly tough to injure.


  • CEAC 16 August 2012

    Some possibly-interesting news going on: As I remarked on Twitter, there are sympathetic protests for the Russian band "Pussy Riot", which…

  • CEAC 08 August 2012

    A fairly lighthearted CEAC: As you may or may not know, Ramadan is a lunar month where muslims fast during the day. In the evening, they naturally…

  • CEAC 31 July 2012

    The usual commentary and news: Human trials are set to begin for a technique to repair spinal cord injury; if this is successful we may see a…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded